Grammatical and psychological reading of Platonov’s ‘Sharmanka’ (Barrel Organ)
https://doi.org/10.28995/2686-7249-2022-6-224-233
Abstract
The article deals with Andrei Platonov’s play “Sharmanka”. Its analysis shows how the author’s original and hidden language relates to the meaning of the text and to the author’s life. The play is also considered in the context of the poetics of the writer’s works close in time: the general tendency of thought, invariance of details and themes; different combinations of motifs and development of some leitmotifs are revealed. The method used is hermeneutics, as it is defined by Friedrich Schleiermacher – the art of understanding and interpreting the text. The “grammatical” and the “psychological” sides in such analysis remain identical – they are not separated, but constantly touching and mutually percepting, like part and parcel in a hermeneutic circle. First of all, that allows to approach the interpretation of difficult parts through the prism of the author’s life, thereby giving them a reasonable and convincing explanation; and secondly, to call “Sharmanka” partly an autobiographical work. Thus, the article studies the originality of Platonov’s language, its connection with the realities of Soviet times in the 20s and 30s; the intersection of the plot with important events in the writer’s life, such as the repudiation of the literary community, in particular his patron and comrade Alexander Fadeev; as well as the place of “Sharmanka” in the creative legacy of Andrei Platonov.
About the Author
E. I. MyasnikovRussian Federation
Elisei I. Myasnikov, student
bld. 6, Miusskaya Sq., Moscow, 125047
References
1. Bocharov, S.G. (2014), Veshhestvo sushhestvovaniya: filologicheskie e`trudy` [The substance of existence. Philological etudes], “Russkіi Mіr”: Zhizn’ i mysl’, Moscow, Russia.
2. Bogomolova, M.V. (2011), “Remarks and their functions in the formation of the author’s position. ‘Barrel organ’ ”, in “Strana filosofov” Andreya Platonova: problemy` tvorchestva [“The Land of Philosophers” by Andrey Platonov. Problematics of his works], IMLI RAN, Moscow, Russia, pp. 104–116.
3. Eliade, M. (1996), Mify, snovideniya, misterii [Myths, dreams, mysteries], REFL-book, Moscow, Russia, Vakler, Kyiv, Ukraine.
4. Geller, M. (1982), Andrei Platonov v poiskax schast`ya [Andrey Platonov in search of happiness], Ymca-Press, Paris, France.
5. Duzhina, N. (2009), “A. Platonov’s play ‘Barrel organ’ in the context of the political and public life of the country”, in Voprosy` literatury, no. 1, pp. 176–207.
6. Kornienko, N.V. (1993), “The history of the text and the biography of A.P. Platonov”, in Zdes’ i teper’ [Here and now], Moscow, Russia.
7. Malygina, N.M. (2011), “Being human is a rarity and a celebration”, in Platonov, A.P. somnivshijsya Makar: Rasskazy` 1920-x godov; Stikhotvoreniya [Doubting Makar. Stories of the 1920s; Poems], Vremya, Moscow, Russia, pp. 494–543.
8. Mal’tseva, T.V. (2008), “Features of the conflict in Platonov’s play ‘Barrel organ’ ”, in Tvorchestvo Andreya Platonova [Works of Andrey Platonov], Mezhdunarodnaya akademicheskaya izdatel’skaya kompaniya “Nauka/Interperiodika”, Saint Petersburg, Russia, pp. 168–176.
9. Platonova, M. (1989), “ ‘Living the main life...’ (A. Platonov in letters to his wife, documents and essays)”, in Platonov, A. “Zhivya glavnoi zhizn`yu...” [“Living the main life...”], Pravda, Moscow, Russia, p. 380.
10. Proskurina, E.N. (2001), Poetika misterial’nosti v proze Andreya Platonova kontsa 20–30-kh godov [The poetics of mysteriousness in Andrey Platonov’s prose of the late 20s–30s], Sibirskii khronograf, Novosibirsk, Russia.
11. Shlejermakher, F. (2004), Germenevtika [Hermeneutics], Evropeiskii dom, Saint Petersburg, Russia.
Review
For citations:
Myasnikov E.I. Grammatical and psychological reading of Platonov’s ‘Sharmanka’ (Barrel Organ). RSUH/RGGU Bulletin: “Literary Teory. Linguistics. Cultural Studies”, Series. 2022;(6 (2)):224-233. (In Russ.) https://doi.org/10.28995/2686-7249-2022-6-224-233